There are indeed many forms of magnesium on the market, some of which are cheaper but which can cause troublesome side-effects (mild diarrhoea) or are less well-absorbed by the body. Others are more expensive but offer greater bioavailability, while others still are specifically formulated for cognitive health. Before we look more closely at these different forms, let’s first examine the potential reasons for taking magnesium supplements.
The body needs magnesium in order to function properly. It is involved in hundreds of different activities such as muscle relaxation, blood coagulation, energy conversion, and blood pressure … Unfortunately, however, in developed countries such as the US, France and the UK, magnesium intake is below the daily amount recommended for more than half the population. What’s more, regular drinkers (1), diabetics (2), women who take oral contraceptives, the over-60s, and people with hypertension have greater requirements for magnesium (3). Some people choose to supplement with magnesium for its therapeutic effects: it reduces the risk of osteoporosis and fractures, lowers blood pressure, may be helpful in relieving migraine and period pain, may improve memory, and helps achieve better glucose control in prediabetics!
In short, magnesium supplementation is worth considering if your diet provides less than 300-420mg a day (4) (which is the case for 1 in 2 of us), or if you suffer from migraines, diabetes, pain, memory problems, osteoporosis or hypertension.
Surprisingly perhaps, few studies have looked at how the various forms of magnesium compare in terms of efficacy. The reason is that absorption of magnesium depends on a great many factors which are not easily reproducible in a scientific setting. But it’s important to know this information as the less absorbable the magnesium is, the less the body will be able to use it and the greater will be its laxative effect! Two factors are significant here: its bioavailability (the ease with which the magnesium enters the bloodstream for use by the body) and its solubility.
Magnesium malate, magnesium chloride, magnesium citrate and magnesium gluconate are the most soluble and bioavailable forms (5). Magnesium orotate, which is usually more expensive, has the additional benefit of carrying some of the magnesium into cells, close to the nucleus and mitochondria, for better mineralisation. More expensive still, L-threonate offers benefits for memory and cognitive function: studies show it produces greater increases in magnesium levels in the brain compared with other forms.
In contrast, magnesium sulfate, magnesium carbonate, magnesium oxide and magnesium hydroxide are best avoided as they are much less bioavailable and have a stronger laxative effect. Inorganic magnesium salts are generally less available than organic salts (6-10) (which also include magnesium glycerophosphate, magnesium pidolate, magnesium taurinate and magnesium arginate).
Note: in the case of deficiency, supplementing with any form of magnesium will have the effect of increasing levels of this mineral in the body. But a supplement that does this more effectively, without triggering attacks of diarrhoea, is obviously preferable. To fully capitalise on magnesium’s therapeutic effects, it’s also advisable to choose the most bioavailable supplements as the higher the level of magnesium ingested, the less effectively it is absorbed.
|Malate||Good||Very good||Contains malic acid, a beneficial chelating agent.|
|Chloride||Good||Very good||Difficult to preserve (very hygroscopic).|
|Gluconate||Very good||Good||Low level of elemental magnesium.|
|Oxide||Bad||Relatively low||Cheapest form.|
|L-Threonate||Good||Good||Increases magnesium levels in the brain.|
|Orotate||Very good||Deposits the minerals inside cells. Optimal mineralisation.|
The form of magnesium, while important, is just one of many factors that influence its absorption. If you take it on a daily basis, it’s important to follow the recommendations below. Essentially, magnesium is absorbed in the small intestine by the passive paracellular pathway (11). Only a minor part is absorbed in the large intestine and colon across cell membranes (12). Absorption begins around an hour after the supplement is ingested and ends after six hours (13). This process is influenced by several limiting or enhancing factors, which may or may not produce unwelcome side effects.
Age. The ability of intestinal cells to allow magnesium to pass into the intermembrane space diminishes with age (14-15).
Intestinal problems. Irritable bowel syndrome, coeliac disease, gut inflammation and all digestive problems reduce magnesium absorption (16-17).
Taking another mineral supplement. Other mineral supplements (zinc, copper, calcium, phosphorus …) reduce magnesium absorption (18-19).
Already having high magnesium levels. Nature is clever: if the body already has enough, its ability to absorb magnesium decreases.
High levels taken in a single dose. Absorption of magnesium is inversely correlated with the dose ingested. In other words, the higher the amount, the lower its ability to be absorbed (20). It is therefore better to spread a daily amount of 400mg of magnesium across three or four doses, choosing a supplement that contains 100mg per tablet (21-22). This is the case for the following four supplements which all offer excellent bioavailability and solubility:
Avoid eating spinach or cabbage within a short time of taking magnesium. They contain oxalic acid, a chelating agent which reduces magnesium absorption.
Taking the supplement with a meal. Magnesium’s bioavailability is higher when it is taken with a meal, probably because intestinal transit slows down (which extends the time the magnesium is exposed to enterocytes) and also because of the presence of other beneficial foods (23).
Even better if the meal contains protein … Protein increases magnesium’s solubility by preventing the precipitation of calcium-magnesium-phosphate complexes.
… and if it’s rich in prebiotics (fibre)! Fibre nourishes beneficial bifidobacteria which produce short-chain fatty acids (propionate, butyrate, lactate) and reduce the pH of the small intestine, two factors which improve magnesium’s transport towards the bloodstream.
Are there any dietary supplements that genuinely help improve memory and cognitive problems?
Scientific studies all confirm that cerebral decline should not be seen as inevitable! There are things you can do to protect, boost and stimulate your cognitive function. Here are five tips to help you preserve your memory.
The experts at SuperSmart have put together this guide which provides everything you need to know about omega-3: their definition, origins, different types, properties, effects, sources and how much omega-3 the body needs …